Card Shops Finder

I'm Board! Games & Family Fun - Middleton

6917 University Ave, Middleton, WI 53562

★★★★★ 4.8 · 679 reviews
PokémonMagic: The Gathering 🃏FNM 🪑Play space 📦Sealed product

Highlights

  • Vibe

    "Friendly, good game selection, good events!"

    — Natasha Hartman

  • 📚Selection

    "Great selection and super helpful staff!"

    — T.R. Fitz-Gibbon

  • 🧠Staff

    "Great selection and super helpful staff!"

    — T.R. Fitz-Gibbon

  • 🎟️Events

    "Great store and excellent, helpful staff! They host a good Magic tournament with a fun/relaxed environment."

    — Jacob K

  • 💵Prices

    "Great place, great prices and great people"

    — David Ibarra

Map

Hours

Monday 10 AM–9 PM
Tuesday 10 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9 PM
Thursday• today 10 AM–9 PM
Friday 10 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10 AM–7 PM
Sunday 11 AM–5 PM

Recent reviews

8 of 679
  • Jessica Piatt ★★★★★

    We took our 6 year old to their Pokemon night, knowing absolutely nothing about how to play the game. The staff (Claire and Dresana) were so incredibly helpful and kind! They gave my son a starter pack with everything needed to play a game, and very patiently played a game with him while coaching my son, my husband, and I on the rules and strategy. They also told him a lot about the cards he has collected from trading at school. It seems like a very nice community! We had previously only been here to purchase games, and they also have a nice selection of board games and puzzles.

    4 months ago

  • Dan Marek

    I've been supporting this store for over 2 years as a player, and every set they keep increasing prices way past MSRP. This set was the worst, going twice as high as MSRP and over $80 more than any other store. They should be ashamed of themselves for treating their customer base like this. I would recommend that you go to any of the other great stores in town. Such a horrible way to treat their base of players. I'll be switching my locals from here to another shop and am going to hard recomend it to all the rest of the players that come on Monday nights.

    3 months ago

  • Matthew Monsour

    This store takes advantage of the scalping that is taking place in the TCG market by charging $215 on a $120 product. They do not care about the gaming community or you as a customer. They just want your money

    5 months ago

  • Nathan K ★★★★★

    Great customer service and selection of products for sale. Plus a fun gaming room in back where you can play and try out game before buying. They have gaming and figure painting nights too

    Edited 7 years ago

  • Shawn ★★★★★

    Great place to visit if you're searching for a new board game. They have a very large selection of new and used games, and a very friendly staff!

    8 years ago

  • Chrissy Jonelis ★★★★

    Looks like a cool place! The prices on games are a good price (from the ones I compared). They have a large new section and in the back right there are consignment games being sold. I love these sections! The games here are listed in condition, any pieces missing, and animals in the house. Prices are not negotiable here In the far back there are many long gaming tables. I did not check the times on this as I don't live in the area. I wouldn't be affraid to come here on a game night tho. The place is clean and open. I did not buy anything, but I saw a few games I wanted to research to

    4 years ago

  • Arden Aze

    This store does not honor pre-order agreements. Most recent example was them committing to a pre-sale price then magically increasing it by $100 at time of delivery, then tried to make up some excuse about tariffs causing the price increase. If they are going to be disreputable with their commitments, they can at least be truthful in their reasoning; but they can't even do that. Save your money for more reputable local game stores such as Pegasus, Misty Mountain, or Mox Mania. Those one's maintain their integrity.

    10 months ago

  • Liam Davies

    Pretty much every time I've been in this store all the items have been overpriced when compared to both MSRP and other local game stores. Additionally, they raised the price on my MTG Final Fantasy collector booster box preorder significantly after I placed the order and shortly after (scalper) prices started to skyrocket. Now, all of the MTG preorders don't list a price at all, which is better but is still a thinly veiled attempt to charge scalper prices for their goods. Do yourself a favor and go to another nearby LGS like Mox Mania or Pegasus.

    10 months ago

More shops near Middleton

Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards

739 N High Point Rd, Madison, WI 53717

★★★★★
4.9 · 232
PokémonYu-Gi-Oh!Sports Cards

Mox Mania, LLC

410 D'onofrio Dr, Madison, WI 53719

★★★★★
4.7 · 382
PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

Westfield Comics - West

7475 Mineral Point Rd #22, Madison, WI 53717

★★★★★
4.7 · 290
Sports Cards 🛡️Grading 🧠Expert staff

Pegasus Games

6640 Odana Rd, Madison, WI 53719

★★★★
4.4 · 380
PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

BMW Sportscards

555 D'onofrio Dr Suite 103, Madison, WI 53719

★★★★★
5.0 · 2,747
PokémonSports Cards 🛡️Grading

Jim's Card Korner LLC

2865 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705

★★★★
4.0 · 84
PokémonSports Cards 🛡️Grading