Lost Trove Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Friendly owner. Amazing store. Highly recommend."

  — R Shack

• 📚Selection

  "The store is super organized and has a great selection of collectibles and cards to choose from. Owner is also really nice and super helpful if you’re looking for something specific. Will be coming back a lot more!"

  — Trinity E

• 🧠Staff

  "Friendly owner. Amazing store. Highly recommend."

  — R Shack

• 💵Prices

  "Amazing store, friendly owner, great stuff for great prices love this place"

  — Carrie Porzadny

Map

Hours

• Daniel Oleszek ★★★★★

  First time visiting. I had a bunch of star wars figures to sell. Gave me a good price. Instead of cash I was able to buy 2 vintage star wars figures for my collection. The owner was very friendly and knowledgeable. I will definitely be coming back. I highly recommend Lost Trove Collectibles to everyone.

  10 months ago

• joseph strieter ★★★★★

  Great service and a very friendly owner made this shop a pleasure to visit. It’s the perfect spot for GI Joe, Transformers, Star Wars, Marvel/DC, Godzilla, and just about any other “nerdy” collectibles you can think of. Prices are very fair (at or below ebay sales value), especially considering it’s a resale shop. I walked out with a Jazz figure and the strong feeling that I’ll definitely be coming back again. Highly recommended!

  5 months ago

• Rose Kolupar ★★★★★

  Awesome place! Excellent customer service. The owner is kind and friendly and has been so generous with my boys and their love of Pokémon cards. We always have a good time when we come here. Good assortment of products, although we typically are shopping for Pokémon product.

  4 months ago

• Kiara A ★★★★★

  An absolutely wonderful place to go for collectibles. The owner, John, has a little bit of everything for everyone and is incredibly knowledgeable about everything he has. A great passion for his store and what he does. Amazing prices for great quality stock. Will definitely be going back, again and again.

  5 months ago

• Leo Synowicz ★★★★★

  Best collector toy store in entire Milwaukee area. New stuff, old stuff, even not so old stuff. Large variety of collectable toys. Best prices in town for buying and selling collectibles. John the owner is the friendliest shop owner I've met in years. If you have a question about toys you can bet he's got an answer.

  Edited 3 months ago

• Cat Y ★★★★★

  The Owner; John is very cool and cares about the collectibles they are selling. Whether you are looking to buy from their store or looking to sell your collection know they will be well cared for. Also if you're looking for something it doesn't hurt to stop on by never know what you will find. 10 out of 10 will come back again. <3

  5 months ago

• Azalia Hanke ★★★★★

  This place is a hidden gem! At first you kinda question whether or not you are in the right place because you enter from the back, but believe me, you are! The owner is an incredibly kind individual, super helpful, and extremely knowledgeable! I went in looking for a specific comic, he helped me find the continuation of said comic, made sure it was a complete, and said he would let me know if the other was found. There is a wide selection of pokémon cards, for an incredibly fair price, standard market, we ended up getting a handful of illustration rares! All in all, the shop is a wonderful

  9 months ago

• WI Watch Guy ★★★★★

  Lost Trove Collectibles is a great toy store. It has always been tiny but mighty, but owner John has now expanded. His inventory is very impressive from new to vintage and with all sorts of properties. He’s very honest, knowledgeable and always a pleasure to deal with. His pricing is at minimum fair and usually very good. If you like Transformers he’s got a lot to offer, but it doesn’t end there. He’s got a lot of Pokémon, comics and more. I’ve been to stores twice as big and they still don’t have a lot of the inventory John has. You’re doing yourself a disservice if you haven’t stopped

  9 months ago