Max Rarity

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Spacious shop, friendly staff, fair prices"

  — Justin Scheibel

• 📚Selection

  "Huge selection of anything you want from sealed product and singles. Great TO as well."

  — Elliott Arroyo

• 🧠Staff

  "Spacious shop, friendly staff, fair prices"

  — Justin Scheibel

• 🎟️Events

  "Amazing experience. Went there for my first pre-release event and had a ton of fun. Everyone was very friendly and kind. Will 100% be going here for all pre release events"

  — M Miraglia

• 💵Prices

  "Spacious shop, friendly staff, fair prices"

  — Justin Scheibel

Map

Hours

• Angelo Vartholomeou ★★★★★

  ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Randy at Max Rarity in Valley Stream was absolutely amazing! He has a fantastic personality, super accommodating, patient, and easy to talk to. The shop itself was clean, well-organized, and had an incredible selection of inventory. Randy took the time to help me pick something out for myself and even got me set up with around 1,000 cards for my kid’s art project. This is exactly what I look for in a trading card store, a place that actually cares about the customer experience. Unfortunately, most local shops don’t compare, but Max Rarity definitely sets the standard. A well-deserve

  7 months ago

• James M ★★★★★

  Great place! Very chill atmosphere and the employees are very helpful and knowledgeable about all products I inquired about (Pokémon & MTG) Because Im disabled I couldn't make it to the most recent prerelease event, but I managed to go there the following week and buy a bunch of packs of MTG for myself and my little bros to share. The pulls were amazing! Not only did we get great cards to add to our collections but even more cards to build and edit our decks with✨️✨️ I will DEFINITELY be returning the next time I can get myself over to their shop! Considering how horrid the market is for price

  11 months ago

• Khoang C ★

  cool shop but they don't honor the official bandai app. you have to pre register on their website which they don't mention on the bandai app. reserving a lot on the official app means nothing which is stupid cause then whats the point. came all the way from the city and got turned away which is understandable cause they're full but the shop should do better and mention that on the official bandai app. good shop with lots of one piece singles though just beware

  4 months ago

• MD Abir Choudhury ★★★★★

  Randy is the best. Always helped me out and always asks what I needed in the few times I've gone. This store has the best pricing structure for all their tcgs and game events I've ever seen. The folks who play are also a vibe. Sometimes its a bit hectic, but thats just the long island vibe. You get all the unique people under one building 💪🏽

  6 months ago

• John Schmaltz ★★★★★

  Great spot. Fit in my Warhammer groups team tournament practice when our regular venue fell through. Great stock and price on minis too. They even had some terrain to play on.

  a year ago

• stevebel6 ★★★★★

  Really excited having a game store like this nearby. Welcoming and laid back. It’s the only place around that you can get reasonable prices on popular Magic and Pokemon releases, and they do their best to make sure people get a chance to buy it. The couple events I attended were great vibes and I’ve already signed up for another. Please support this store and keep them around!

  10 months ago

• Jeremy Ashton ★★★★★

  5 stars for the Sunday Dungeons and Dragons. I was a bit nervous as a very new player, but everyone at the table was so friendly and willing to help me out as I learned the game. Excited to have found a friendly space for my new hobby. There was a $10 charge for DND but $5 goes to store credit (I used it for their snacks) and I think the DM/experience I had with the other players was well worth the other $5 - I’m excited to meet more people here and keep building my DND character

  9 months ago

• MoonShade ★★★★★

  Came here for a release drop. They cut the wrappers from the boxes. HUGE WIN for Max Rarity!!!!! Wished every store would do the same. Will definitely come again!

  6 months ago