Papa Joey’s Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Really fun store with Really good cards and the workers are really fun such a good vibe"

  — Merrick Macias

• 📚Selection

  "I like that they have lightly played and damaged singles at discounted prices"

  — Vance Petitti

• 🧠Staff

  "Very helpful and nice finding what cards you need! Great customer service!"

  — Nicolas Pizarro

• 🎟️Events

  "Really great store. It’s huge and has tons of selection and tables to play. Carson was awesome and ran the MTG draft. Super fun experience and will be back. Highly recommend coming for the drafts on Sunday. Very affordable and great location."

  — Yoav Grossman

• 💵Prices

  "I like that they have lightly played and damaged singles at discounted prices"

  — Vance Petitti

Map

Hours

• Gravishh ★★★★★

  This place is amazing they do fair deals and trades when I came for the first time yesterday and they noticed I didn’t have sleeves on any of my cards and RJ gave me a full pack of sleeves for free and Dave helped me and gave me the best prices for the pokemon cards I sold to them. I really recommend to come here and buy,sell, and play card games with your friends in store they have tables and chairs to play overall 100% satisfied

  5 months ago

• Josephine Alvarez ★★★★★

  Such a cool place ! Started a binder with my 9 year old, and we love to hop in a few times a month to buy packs to rip. Staff is super friendly and that’s the main reason we keep coming back. My 5 year old once got a free pack and it totally made her day. Some people have mentioned the prices are a bit high, but some fail to take into consideration the overhead costs of running a business especially a storefront at Plaza. I’d say they are pretty reasonable.

  3 months ago

• Samit Datta ★★★★★

  Got a couple high end products from here. I wonder about reviews complaining about pricing. Smart card businesses will keep their prices higher, but the margin here was around 10%. They are receptive to offers as well and both products I got were within 5% of market price. It is a market that fluctuates day by day. Use tcgplayer, pricecharting, and card ladder. The truth of a volatile market is you have to do your research. I think the other thing people forget when it comes to trades. Businesses are paying you to take 100% of the risk selling your card. There is opportunity cost to that. Yo

  4 months ago

• Ed Estrella ★★★★★

  The shop was clean and spacious, with lots of items to look at. Gabby and Landon were great, they are very knowledgable and friendly. I also spoke to a manager, though I didn’t get his name, but I saw a card I liked and talked to him briefly about the pricing. He was willing to work with me, which I thought was considerate. I’ll definitely be coming back.

  3 months ago

• Anthony Edrozo ★★★★★

  Came in here today for the first time and had such a great experience! Really big space and tons of products, RJ gave the best customer experience and was really personable! Can’t wait to see how much this place grows, I think it’s a great addition to this mall! I’ll definitely be coming back here for all my TCG products.

  4 months ago

• Matthew McConnaughey ★★★★★

  Came to the mall to find cards and found out this shop had opened up. Staff was really friendly and prices were on point with market. Will now be coming once a week!

  4 months ago

• Antonia Veyna ★★★★★

  Staff is super friendly and helpful! The area is big and there’s always space for you to hop in, rip some packs and enjoy. Many of the staff are very knowledgeable about the cards you are looking for. They always ask if you need help, or if there’s something catching your eye! There’s a lot of bulk as well. Again, this is a great place to hang out with people who have the same interests!

  5 months ago

• Richard Funtanilla ★★★★★

  Brandon & R.J. were awesome staff from the first time I walked in. Friendly, knowledgeable, and masters of their craft, my buying and selling experience was excellent. Both took the time to explain how store policy works, along with how valuable my items were. Will definitely be back as a return patron.

  4 months ago