Card Shops Finder

The Game Cave

3824 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY 14616

★★★★☆ 4.4 · 68 reviews
PokémonMagic: The Gathering 🃏FNM 🧠Expert staff 🏠Owner-run

Highlights

  • Vibe

    "Went here on christmas eve right before they closed it was my first time ever buying any cards from them but it was a great experience extremely nice and helpful employees and really good and fairly priced cards compared to other places definitely my new favorite local card shop will be going again soon very welcoming!"

    — Angel rios

  • 🧠Staff

    "Went here on christmas eve right before they closed it was my first time ever buying any cards from them but it was a great experience extremely nice and helpful employees and really good and fairly priced cards compared to other places definitely my new favorite local card shop will be going again soon very welcoming!"

    — Angel rios

Map

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 6–9 PM
Wednesday 1–9 PM
Thursday• today 1–9 PM
Friday 1–9 PM
Saturday 12–7 PM
Sunday 12–7 PM

Recent reviews

8 of 68
  • ASaul 15 ★★★★★

    I highly recommend this place. I stopped in to place a pre- order, and I am new to the hobby of magic the gathering. One of the owners, (I am terrible with names so apologizes man, you were so great and cool.) stopped everything and answered every single one of my questions and gave me so much good advice. There was also a bunch of people hanging out playing games, super chill vibes. If you new or old to the hobby, please take a moment to stop in and I promise you won’t regret it. They had packs, single cards, sleeves mats, everything you would need, and other card packs as well.

    5 months ago

  • Jack Parnell ★★★★★

    One of the best experiences I've had in a collectible card gaming store. The two guys working today were extremely helpful, knowledgeable, kind and patient with me. I'm a casual player, looking for commander precons to play with my wife who is even more casual than I am. These gentlemen are trying to start a presale event when I show up and they gave me their attention and were patient with me when I wasn't prepared for the amount of selection they had available. They allowed me to take my time selecting some precons and I never felt rushed or pressured, as a new player, I am eternally gratefu

    6 months ago

  • Liam Bedard

    I went in and asked for 2 Pokemon chests , the guy working the counted made a comment that shouldn’t have been made outloud to a child. I then asked the price and it was a 100$. I was told over the phone it was going to be 50$. He then gets an attitude with my son for reading the price wrong. When asked after SPENDING MONEY IN THE STORE to support my local card shop he insults me by saying that I do a horrible job at keeping my cards in perfect condition in the rudest way possible. He proceeded to lowball the absolute crap out of my son. Overall just horrible attitude and horrible customer ser

    5 months ago

  • Angel rios ★★★★★

    Went here on christmas eve right before they closed it was my first time ever buying any cards from them but it was a great experience extremely nice and helpful employees and really good and fairly priced cards compared to other places definitely my new favorite local card shop will be going again soon very welcoming!

    5 months ago

  • Doc Salem

    Or the course of 2 days I spent almost $100 at this place buying cards my first box pulled absolutely nothing second box once again pulled no uncommons and no rares upon going through the cards feeling somewhat suspicious out of 10 packs nothing being pulled multiple cards have damage on the front of them like a pack had been cut open or something heavy left on them inspecting the packs also showed residue of some sort and what look to be re-crimping I have no idea if the store is doing this or if the supplier is but I am definitely not spending any more money here.

    2 years ago

  • Fabiano Sarra ★★★★★

    I stopped in here for the first time last week with my cousin for Friday night magic. I had never played draft before and I was happy to find all the participants to be really patient and welcoming to beginners. I like playing casually and it seems like that was very much the vibe here. Everyone was there to have a good time and play some magic. The owner was also very nice and made sure we were pleased with our experience in store. I had a great time and I hope to be back soon for more fun!

    a year ago

  • Kevin Healey ★★★★★

    Looking for a great Magic the Gathering community? Lots of laughs? Knowledgeable and friendly staff?! Then look no further then The Game Cave, Greece! Roy and owner Brandon are a pleasure to talk to. They have competitive pricing on a multitude of tcgs/ccgs. But this isn't all they carry as you can find Warhammer, D&D and accessories galore. Be sure to give them a try next time you are looking for some new Pokemon, Magic, FaB or other games. Stop by for Friday night draft or Commander all weekend! Hope to see you there!

    Edited 5 months ago

  • tommy accorso ★★★

    There alright when it comes to there magic but they wanted to charge my girlfriend 30$ for a pokemon card, witch I get some are can definitely be worth that. But when we look up TCG prices, it's 5$ I understand making a profit but That's just not cool.

    9 months ago

More shops near Rochester

Rhino's Comics & Collectibles

3805 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY 14616

★★★★★
4.9 · 250
🧠Expert staff 🏠Owner-run

Leone’s Collectibles

612 Stone Rd, Rochester, NY 14616

★★★★
4.2 · 43
Sports Cards 🏛️Vintage 😎Casual

Game On!!

2670 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY 14616

★★★★
4.4 · 41
Sports Cards 🏛️Vintage 🎴Singles

All Heroes Comics

4410 Lake Ave, Rochester, NY 14612

★★★★★
4.7 · 80
🧠Expert staff 🏠Owner-run

In The Zone

162 Greece Ridge Center Dr, Rochester, NY 14626

★★★★
3.8 · 23
PokémonYu-Gi-Oh!Sports Cards

Endzone Collectibles

162 Greece Ridge Center Dr, Rochester, NY 14626