Centre City Sports Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "From upstate NY. Went there with my son. Owner was very friendly and welcoming. My son was excited that he had the cards he was looking for at a fair price."

  — Edward Noonan

• 📚Selection

  "Insane selection! If you need anything, chances are it’s there!"

  — Austin Ball

• 🧠Staff

  "I really like the owner. I think I got a really good deal."

  — Brad Mider

• 💵Prices

  "I really like the owner. I think I got a really good deal."

  — Brad Mider

About this shop

Wall-to-wall sports memorabilia fills this store catering to casual fans & serious collectors alike.

Map

Hours

• Brian Kelly ★★★★★

  Owner was super friendly and helpful. Son said his football card prices and selection was awesome! Recommend going there with an idea of what you want and let him bring stuff to you. Would definitely go back!

  3 months ago

• Benjamin Lacher ★

  This store is incredibly unorganized. There’s clutter EVERYWHERE. It’s clear the owner is a hoarder. There is virtually nothing accessible to the customer, and the owner will stand there, staring at you and asking what you are looking for. In my case, the owner could not provide any assistance in looking cards of a specific MLB team. The wax prices are high and exceed market price. The store itself is dirty, dusty and stinks. There are homeless people strewn across the sidewalk in front of the store, making the egress into the “business” both difficult and stressful. I would not waste your tim

  4 months ago

• Kyle Simington ★★★★★

  This store is authentic as It gets. The owner is also the only employee and knows and clearly loves what he does. Sure, the store is disorganized to the new walk in customer, but the owner knows where everything is, the epitome of organized chaos. I’d recommend to come here having an idea of what you are looking for. I purchased vintage pokemon card singles and was amazed to see everything from 1st editions, unlimited, base set 2, jungle, rocket and more. This place is certainly an experience for a collector. Lastly, the building this store is in was built in the 1800s and was previously a mov

  2 years ago

• Ricky J VanFleet ★★★★★

  Henry that's the name I used to call him by between 1993- 2007. I frequently sold my collectables and a very fair price was paid. Henry made me feel right at home. Excellent Atmosphere. You are over whelmed by the amount of collectibles Henry has gathered through the years. A must stop in to see place. what he has in it may surprise you. He has his own method for a filing things. you gotta respect that old school system. Just like your Dad did and now Hopefully You Too. I very Highly Recommend this Shop for True San Diego Sports Fans Looking for that Childhood Sports item you want back in You

  7 months ago

• 11JJXD ★★★★★

  Very uh, unorganized looking but honestly a very good selection of older cards and newer cards! It might look intimidating from the other reviews but the owner is a nice person, but the area down town might have you looking for parking for awhile! But if you can make it come! Very good stock of old Yugioh sealed products!

  2 years ago

• Miranmao Schweiz ★★★★★

  I arrived today as an European tourist at this shop, which already looked very interesting from the outside (apparently it used to be a cinema). I was greeted by an extremely friendly gentleman and was fascinated by everything he had to offer in his shop. Unfortunately, I only had a little space left in my suitcase for the journey home, so I only bought a few packs of baseball cards from him. One of them even had a cool hit in it (see one of my photos). I can only recommend this shop to any collector of sports memorabilia 👍🏻

  a year ago

• August Back ★

  I recently visited Centre City Sports Collectibles, hoping to find some quality sports memorabilia, but unfortunately, my experience was extremely disappointing from start to finish. To be completely honest, the shop itself is an absolute mess. Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the overwhelming clutter and disorganization. Instead of a clean, inviting space where collectibles are thoughtfully displayed, the store felt like a chaotic hoarding location. Items were piled haphazardly, making it difficult to even browse through the inventory without knocking something over or feeling like

  7 months ago

• Victor Caymaris ★★★★★

  This place is special. Disregard the negative impressions, go and make up your own mind, this store is unlike others and you may find really niche collectibles and memorabilia, mostly focused on Sports obviously, but also carries a lot more (both currently popular and old schools TCGs). It's also, impressively, open seven days a week and operated by the store owner, who is kind, welcoming and knowledgeable.

  8 months ago