Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles
256 Main St, Phelps, NY 14532
Highlights
- 📚Selection
"For my "first" time in this shop, the experience was stellar. Was treated absolutely amazing and given a lot of information about what I could expect there. Selection is good and will continue to get better i expect. Will be back for sure, and cant wait for the card show that the owner puts on. 10/10 reccomend a visit."
— Greyson Blanchard
- 🧠Staff
"Always a fun visit to the shop. Good prices. Knowledgeable owners."
— Brian V
- 💵Prices
"Sweet shop, fair prices. Love of the hobby!!"
— travis morgan
Map
Hours
| Monday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Thursday• today | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–6 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–5 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–4 PM |
Recent reviews
8 of 34- Brian Farrell ★★★★★
This place is AMAZING!!! I found them a few years ago, and even though its almost an hour from my house I stop in regularly. Whether you are looking for BIG cards or small ones they have something for everyone. Great prices, great inventory, and great breaks! They regularly host fun events for the hobby but the biggest asset is the staff. They are some of the nicest, helpful people i have met in the hobby! This place should be a model for the hobby...check it out!
3 months ago
- Trixare4fatkids ★
Called for inventory/price check on cards. Was able to tell me they have a ton. But Would not give price to me over the phone. which is instant redflag that they are charging way over MSRP
4 months ago
- Tom Meyer ★★★★★
Great people and store! Lots of fun to be there ripping packs and talking cards.
3 months ago
- Brian V ★★★★★
Always a fun visit to the shop. Good prices. Knowledgeable owners.
3 months ago
- Greyson Blanchard ★★★★★
For my "first" time in this shop, the experience was stellar. Was treated absolutely amazing and given a lot of information about what I could expect there. Selection is good and will continue to get better i expect. Will be back for sure, and cant wait for the card show that the owner puts on. 10/10 reccomend a visit.
8 months ago
- Jay Jugovic ★★★★★
Went here with my son and had an amazing time. Eric the owner was super friendly, and had an amazing selection from modern to vintage. The experience in the shop was phenomenal. We each bought packs, talked collecting and had a great time opening some cool cards. Prices are extremely fair, and inventory seemed to have something for everyone. Would highly recommend checking this place out.
a year ago
- travis morgan ★★★★★
Sweet shop, fair prices. Love of the hobby!!
3 months ago
- Mike Fuentes ★★★★★
What a great shop! I finally got a chance to stop in and poke around. Lots of solid choices from packs, single cards, collectables, etc. Love the fact they have tables for you to sit down at while browsing through the binders & cards. The owner Eric is very friendly & knowledgeable - I enjoyed talking with him. Phelps is very lucky to have this little gem of a shop.
a year ago
More shops near Phelps
Dork Forest Comics
18 E Main St, Clifton Springs, NY 14432
Mystify Games
655 NY-318 #47, Waterloo, NY 13165
GI Cards and Collectibles
433 Exchange St, Geneva, NY 14456
Smitty's Coins and Currency East
80 S Main St, Canandaigua, NY 14424