Overtime Cards

Map

Hours

• Brian H. (Brody) ★★★★★

  Came in about a week ago now needing some sleeves and decided to buy a box as well. Just moved and needed a new local and my first run here was great. Guys up front all seemed really cool and the store was fairly busy right after opening but not crazy at all. Was good to see that amount of people in a card shop again. Thanks again guys and definitely will be back👍🏻

  4 months ago

• Spencer Toone ★★★★★

  I really love coming to Overtime Cards! All of the people here are very kind and always willing to make deals with me. Chris the owner is a very cool and nice guy. He was very generous and gave my brother and I both a pack of topps chrome basketball for good grades. Which we both got some good stuff out of. I'm looking forward to the card show that OT Cards sponsors in February. Always a fun show with cool giveaways. Great employees, great shop, great selection of packs, boxes and singles! Good job Overtime Cards and congrats on the new store!

  4 months ago

• Cardboard Stoic ★★★★★

  Absolutely gorgeous store with the friendliest employees. You can tell they genuinely want to foster community and get players their products at a fair price. I would be shocked if I ever buy Pokemon from another physical retailer ever again. Chauncey (possibly misspelling that) made such an impression and deserves all the praise. Seriously awesome game store. I can not wait for them to start hosting events.

  6 months ago

• Kameron Henricksen ★★★★★

  100/10 I bought 3 Micheal Jordan basketball cards and 1 John Stockton basketball card and 15 dollars worth of 100 MLB cards. It is my favorite sports card store. I was in my dream place.

  4 months ago

• B Vuong ★★★★★

  Great place! Amazing staff, always took care of me. Product for MSRP on release day. I always wanted to submit to PSA but didn't know how or what to do. They helped you out so much here. From Kevin looking at your cards to determine and everyone else that helps submitting the cards, tracking orders, my cards for damaged on transit and they resent it to get reslabbed by PSA. Best experience ever for my first time grading. Everyone would always be helpful and friendly

  3 months ago

• Jason Theisen ★

  So I went to make a simple purchase would have taken less than 2 minutes to complete the transaction but some chad decided to lecture me that they weren't open for 20 minutes... when there 3 of them there in the store... buy from Amazon instead and stay away from this place... in the time he explained to me that he wouldn't take my money he could have had it and I'd been gone and happy... customer service 😆 🤣 do NOT recommend

  3 months ago

• Deidre Salas ★★★★★

  My boyfriend and I drove here from Austin, TX for a snowboarding trip. He’s big into sports cards and we came across a few in the area. We stopped by Overtime first. The owner himself was helping out my boyfriend a lot, but all of the employees were very nice and helpful. We checked out a couple other spots around town, but the other stores simply did not compare to the atmosphere and service received at Overtime. Even our local stores back home are not as friendly and welcoming. We will definitely be coming back next time we are in town!

  4 months ago

• Nate Griffith ★

  It's true. They might have a selection but the owner is not easy to deal with. I usually go to Beehive Sports Cards in Ogden for my nephew's Christmas gift but, short on time ended up here instead. They did not have what I wanted so I opted to purchase a gift card instead. They didn't have any physical gift cards at the moment so I bought a emailed gift card instead. I was told to come back in a week or two if I wanted a physical card. I went back today and got a pretentious jerk to "help" me. He told me that they didn't have physical cards yet. When I asked when they would have them he kep

  4 months ago